Early ERIE Cast Iron: How to Identify Pre-Griswold Skillets

looking at cast iron cookware in thrift store

Affiliate disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Please see full disclosure.

An early ERIE cast iron skillet has a prominent ERIE marking underneath, but the lettering alone won’t tell you its age. Check the heat ring, handle shape, and pattern numbers together. Those details help identify the skillet’s generation. Condition is a separate question, and an old marking doesn’t make a damaged pan worth cooking with.

As a thrifter and collector, I want the markings and the condition to justify bringing a pan home.

Read the ERIE mark in context

Underside of an ERIE skillet showing the ERIE mark, inset heat ring, and handle
image credit: leosellsit978 via eBay

ERIE skillets were manufactured in Erie, Pennsylvania, by Selden & Griswold and later Griswold Manufacturing, roughly between 1880 and 1907. The name identifies the city, but ERIE was also the brand displayed prominently on these early pans.

Collectors often call them pre-Griswold skillets. That’s convenient shorthand rather than a strictly accurate historical description. The Griswold family was involved from the beginning, so ERIE wasn’t some unrelated manufacturer that Griswold subsequently acquired. The early branding and casting variations reflect changes within the company’s own production.

The ERIE lettering changed over time. Most examples have straightforward block lettering, while one later variation features a distinctive, almost squiggly design. Quotation marks appear on many earlier ERIE skillets, generally across the first five collector series, while the sixth typically omits them. There are exceptions and overlapping features, though, so missing quotation marks don’t automatically establish a precise production date.

Don’t confuse the standalone ERIE trademark with ERIE PA USA on later Griswold cookware, either. That wording identifies the manufacturing location rather than the early trademark. The broader Griswold identification details are useful when you’re comparing different markings.

Match the heat ring, handle, and numbers

Close view of the 704 pattern number and size 8 on an ERIE skillet base
image credit: leosellsit978 via eBay

Turn the skillet upside down and examine the heat ring first. This raised ridge underneath the pan might sit near the outside edge or farther inward. Its position is one of the strongest clues to an ERIE skillet’s approximate age.

The earliest ERIE skillets generally had outside heat rings. Inset rings appeared on later examples, although some transitional designs were produced with either arrangement. I wouldn’t date a skillet from its heat ring without checking the handle as well.

The earliest collector series, generally dated around 1880 to 1886, featured a distinctive scooped recess underneath the handle near its teardrop-shaped hanging opening. The next generations typically had ribbed handles instead. Those earliest skillets also lacked the familiar three-digit pattern numbers, which appeared on subsequent versions.

Numbers need careful interpretation, too. A large 8, for example, identifies the traditional skillet size, not an eight-inch diameter. If you’re choosing cookware for a particular burner, measure it rather than relying on the number.

Three-digit numbers identify casting patterns, not manufacturing years. A No. 8 ERIE skillet might carry the pattern number 704, but that’s not universal across early ERIE production. Nor does finding 704 automatically prove who made a particular pan.

Small letters or pictorial symbols can be pattern-maker marks rather than pattern numbers. And a letter following a three-digit number isn’t a secret year code. The different types of cast iron markings are worth understanding before drawing conclusions from them.

Treat ghost marks as clues, not proof

Wapak skillet base with a faint ERIE ghost mark below the stronger WAPAK lettering
image credit: retro_toyz via eBay

Occasionally, you’ll come across a skillet with faint ERIE lettering underneath another manufacturer’s clearer marking. This may be a ghost mark, and it’s an interesting piece of casting history.

A ghost mark can appear when a casting pattern was altered but traces of the previous lettering remained. Those traces were then reproduced in subsequent castings.

It doesn’t mean somebody stamped ERIE onto a finished skillet, or that years of cooking wore away one logo to reveal another.

More importantly, a ghosted ERIE mark doesn’t necessarily mean Griswold manufactured the pan. Other foundries, including Wapak, produced cookware bearing traces of earlier ERIE markings.

I’d examine the stronger manufacturer’s mark alongside the handle, heat ring, and overall casting rather than treating the faint lettering as definitive evidence. Photograph the entire underside, handle, and markings if you need to compare them later.

And don’t assume every faint marking is a ghost. Rust, accumulated grease, and heavy seasoning can obscure ordinary lettering.

Check the pan before choosing it

Close view of an ERIE skillet handle, tapered neck, and teardrop hanging hole
image credit: leosellsit978 via eBay

Once you’ve found a promising ERIE skillet, forget its age for a moment and examine it as cookware.

I start with cracks, particularly around the walls, rim, and handle junction. Hairline damage can be surprisingly difficult to see. Inspect suspicious areas from both sides under angled light. Tapping the pan and listening for a clear ring isn’t a reliable guarantee that it’s sound. Personally, I’d pass on a cracked example intended for cooking.

Next, place the skillet on a known-flat, hard surface. If it rocks, the bottom may be warped downward. An upward bow is harder to spot because the heat ring can keep the pan sitting steadily. Check the interior with a straightedge, allowing for the normal curved transition into the walls. A warped cooking floor can send oil pooling toward one area instead of spreading evenly.

Pitting deserves attention, too. A few tiny cosmetic pits wouldn’t necessarily put me off, especially on the exterior. Deep, rough pitting across the cooking surface is different. That’s lost metal, and seasoning won’t replace it.

When thrifting, I like having a small flashlight for inspecting old cast iron. Thick crust, rust, and old seasoning can conceal damage, so I judge what I can actually see rather than assuming everything underneath is fine. For an online purchase, I’d want clear photographs of the interior and entire underside.

I’d also avoid sanding, grinding, or aggressively polishing an old ERIE skillet just to make it look new. Collector-conscious restoration shouldn’t sacrifice the original surface unnecessarily.

Given the choice between a beautifully marked skillet with a questionable cooking floor and a less distinctive example with sound, usable iron, I’d choose the latter for my kitchen.

You might also like…

The Old Cast-Iron Skillet Collectors Are Always on the Hunt For

How to Rescue a Rusty Cast-Iron Pan and When It’s Time To Give Up

24 Cast Iron Skillet Recipes for Simple, Hearty Homestead Meals




Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *