Affiliate disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Please see full disclosure.
There is a particular kind of optimism involved in opening a meal-kit box at 5:30 p.m. and believing dinner is basically done. Everything is portioned. The recipe card is pretty. Nobody has to decide what to cook. Then you realize you still have to chop the vegetables, brown the meat, make the sauce, wash the pan, and answer 14 questions from your children while doing it.
I completely understand the appeal of meal kits. As a busy mom and a fairly stubborn from-scratch cook, I think the hardest part of feeding a family every night is often not the cooking. It’s deciding what we’re having and making sure the ingredients are actually in the house. Meal kits solve both problems beautifully. They just solve them at a crazy price.
My preferred alternative is much less glamorous. About once a month, I set aside a couple of hours and make a small number of freezer-friendly meals in big batches. I’m not filling the freezer with 30 different Pinterest dinners or spending my entire Sunday meal-prepping tiny containers. I make four to six reliable things, portion them properly, label them, and stop.
Once those meals are in the freezer, I get the bit of meal kits I actually want: dinner has already been decided. Except I can pull out a homemade chili, curry, stew, or meat sauce for a few dollars per serving and spend very little active time getting it onto the table.
The price difference is not subtle
Meal kits aren’t cheap groceries. You’re paying for someone else to plan the meal, portion the ingredients, package everything separately, and bring it to your door. That’s a legitimate service, but it costs money.
Current Blue Apron meal-kit listings run roughly $10.49 to $14.99 per serving, depending on the dish. Its white bean chicken chili, for example, is currently listed at $13.99 per serving. Feed four people and that’s $55.96 for one dinner at the listed meal price.
A homemade pot of chicken and white bean chili is nowhere close to that. At current Walmart online prices, fresh boneless chicken breast is around $2.57 per pound, cannellini beans are about $0.92 per can, a 48-ounce carton of chicken broth is $2.16, and a can of diced tomatoes is $0.96. A three-pound bag of yellow onions has recently been around $2.50 to $3.24, depending on location and promotion.
Using 1 1/2 pounds of chicken, two cans of beans, 32 ounces of broth, tomatoes, onion, and allowing another $1.50 or so for garlic, oil, and seasonings puts a six-serving pot at roughly $10. That’s around $1.70 per serving before toppings. Even if your local groceries cost more, or you throw in corn, green chiles, cheese, and sour cream, there’s a lot of room between $2 or $3 and $13.99.
Beef sauce tells a similar story. Ground beef is considerably more expensive right now, at around $6.28 per pound for one current 80/20 Walmart option. But 1 1/2 pounds of beef with canned tomatoes, tomato sauce, onion, seasonings, and a $1 box of spaghetti still comes in somewhere around $2.50 to $3 per serving for six people.
Those are basic supermarket prices, not fantasy calculations based on using 3 cents’ worth of an onion and pretending everything else materialized in the pantry for free.
I don’t prep 20 different meals
This is where freezer meal prep often gets ridiculous. Search for batch cooking ideas and you’ll find people apparently preparing enough individually different meals to stock a small restaurant. I have neither the patience nor the counter space for that.
The most efficient version is repetitive on purpose. Pick four to six things you already know your household eats. Make large quantities. If your family happily eats chili twice in a month, you do not need two different chili recipes purely for the sake of novelty.
I usually think in categories rather than specific meal plans. One big soup or stew. One tomato-based meat sauce. One curry. One braised or shredded meat. A couple of bags of marinated raw chicken or pork. Then I might add some cooked beans or another useful base ingredient.
That gives me options without turning prep day into an eight-hour ordeal. A bag of shredded meat can become tacos, rice bowls, sandwiches, or baked potatoes. Tomato meat sauce can go over freshly cooked pasta, into lasagna, or onto a baked potato. Marinated chicken can be roasted with whatever vegetables need using.
This also makes shopping much cheaper because I’m deliberately overlapping ingredients. If three dishes need onions, I buy the big bag. If I’m already opening tomato paste for one pot, I choose another meal that’ll use the rest. That sounds painfully sensible, I know, but painfully sensible is quite useful when groceries cost what they currently do.
Soups, stews, curries, and sauces earn their freezer space
If I’m giving something valuable freezer real estate, it needs to come back out tasting like actual dinner.
Soups, stews, chili, braised meats, curries, and tomato-based sauces are my workhorses because they generally reheat extremely well. In many cases, the flavors are arguably better after they’ve sat together for a while. The main caveat is what you put in them. A beef stew itself freezes beautifully. Big chunks of cooked potato inside it may not.
I also freeze cooked beans regularly. They’re inexpensive, useful, and much nicer to have waiting in meal-sized amounts than discovering at 6 p.m. that the dried beans you intended to use require several hours of your life.
Cooked grains can also be handy freezer building blocks, although I don’t pretend every grain comes back exactly as it went in. Rice, in particular, can soften after freezing and thawing, and food-preservation guidance notes that cooked rice and pasta may turn mushy when frozen separately. If slightly softer rice bothers you, freeze the curry and cook the rice fresh. It takes very little active work anyway.
One of my favorite freezer tricks is not cooking the protein at all. Put raw chicken, pork, or beef into a freezer bag with its marinade, squeeze out the excess air, label it, and freeze it. Thaw it safely in the refrigerator and the main part of dinner is already seasoned and ready for the oven, skillet, or grill. Raw meat should always be thawed and marinated under refrigeration, not sitting out on the counter.
Casseroles and bakes are useful, too. Depending on the recipe, you can either assemble them and freeze before baking or cook them first and freeze portions. This is particularly handy for nights when various family members are eating at different times.
Some foods come back from the freezer thoroughly disappointing
Not everything belongs in there. I learned a long time ago that being technically freezable and being worth freezing are two completely different things.
Cooked pasta is the big one. Freeze the sauce, not the spaghetti. Fully cooked pasta has a habit of coming back soft and slightly swollen, particularly when it’s frozen sitting in sauce. A pot of dried pasta takes 10 minutes or so anyway, and most of that time involves leaving it alone in boiling water.
Cooked potatoes in soups and stews are another repeat offender. They can become mealy, watery, or oddly grainy after thawing.
Dairy-heavy sauces can split, particularly milk sauces, sour cream mixtures, and some cream-based gravies. Again, I’d rather freeze the main base and stir the dairy in during reheating than risk producing a sauce that looks curdled and greasy.
Then there are high-water vegetables. Nobody sensible is freezing lettuce for next month’s salad, but cucumber has the same problem, and zucchini can be deceptive. Zucchini contains so much water that freezing damages its cell structure and it can become distinctly watery once thawed. It’s fine when that texture doesn’t matter, such as grated zucchini destined for baking, but I wouldn’t load a freezer stew with chunks of it and expect them to return intact.
The freezer is not magic. It stops you wasting food only if the food coming out is something you still want to eat.
My batch-cooking session starts with the slowest pot
The trick to getting several meals done in two or three hours is not cooking them one after another. If you make a stew, clean everything, then start chili, then clean everything, then begin a curry, you’ll still be standing in the kitchen at midnight wondering why you ever listened to me.
I run jobs simultaneously. Something long and slow goes on first, then I use its cooking time for everything else. My basic order looks like this:
- Start braised meats, dried beans, stock-based soups, or anything else with a long cooking time.
- Chop all the onions, garlic, carrots, peppers, and similar ingredients at once instead of repeatedly getting the knife and cutting board dirty.
- Get the second and third pots cooking while the first one simmers.
- Mix and bag raw marinated proteins while the cooked meals finish.
- Portion cooked food into smaller, shallow containers so it cools quickly, then refrigerate or freeze it promptly.
- Label every package with the meal, date, and exactly what it needs later, such as “thaw overnight, 25 minutes at 375 degrees” or “reheat, add cream, serve with rice.”
One food-safety point matters here. Don’t leave a giant stockpot of chili sitting on the counter for hours because you’ve heard food has to be completely cold before it goes into the refrigerator. It doesn’t. Large amounts should be divided into shallow containers and refrigerated promptly so they cool quickly, and perishable foods shouldn’t sit at room temperature for more than two hours.
That slightly changes the old-school advice to “cool everything completely before freezing.” I cool food quickly and safely, portion it, chill it, then get it properly frozen. I do not wait half the evening for six quarts of stew to cool itself.
Good packaging is the difference between dinner and an icy brick
Freezer burn is one of the quickest ways to make this whole system feel like a failure. You do all that work, proudly pull out your homemade dinner six weeks later, and find grayish dried edges and enough ice crystals to build a small snowman.
Air is the problem. Poor packaging lets moisture escape from the food, which contributes to freezer burn and quality loss. Removing as much excess air as possible and using proper freezer-grade packaging makes an enormous difference.
For soups and stews, I like rigid freezer containers or heavy freezer bags. For sauces, beans, grains, and marinated proteins, bags are particularly useful because I can freeze them flat, then stand them upright once solid. It’s essentially a filing cabinet full of dinner.
And please label them before they freeze. Once tomato sauce, chili, curry, and beef stew are all frozen into dark reddish-brown rectangles, your confidence in your ability to recognize them will prove wildly misplaced. House Digest has covered the same principle when discussing portioning and organizing bulk freezer food: portion things into usable quantities, freeze bags flat, and label what you’ve stored.
I add reheating instructions because Future Me is busy and has forgotten every clever plan Prep-Day Me made.
The time savings happen on ordinary Tuesday nights
Meal kits save planning and shopping time. I won’t argue with that. But most still require you to actually make dinner. HelloFresh says its typical meals take about 30 minutes, with quicker options under 20 minutes, while current Blue Apron listings range from 15-minute dishes to meals taking 40 minutes or more.
Freezer cooking moves most of that labor to one chosen block of time.
If I spend 2 1/2 hours on a batch session, I may have several complete dinners plus sauces, proteins, and building blocks waiting for me. Reheating a frozen chili might take 20 or 30 minutes, but I am not standing over it for 30 minutes. It’s on the stove at low heat while I empty the dishwasher, help with homework, feed animals, put laundry away, or stand in the kitchen eating shredded cheese directly from the bag. I’m still human.
Even on a night when I have to boil pasta or cook rice, my actual involvement might be 5 or 10 minutes. Dinner itself takes longer than that to become hot, obviously, but the stove does not require emotional support while water boils.
That’s the bit I think gets missed when people compare meal prep times. Thirty minutes of active chopping, stirring, browning, and following a recipe is not the same as 30 minutes during which a saucepan quietly reheats something you already made.
I don’t use freezer prep because I particularly enjoy devoting an afternoon to chopping onions. I use it because I would rather chop six onions once than chop one onion at 5:45 p.m. six different times. And once those dinners are frozen, I’ve solved the same problem the meal-kit box was solving. I already know what’s for dinner. I’ve just paid a lot less for the answer.
