35 Budget-Friendly Thanksgiving Side Dishes That Still Feel Special

Roasted acorn squash with raisins on a white serving plate

Affiliate disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Please see full disclosure.

Thanksgiving has a way of turning a perfectly sensible grocery list into a rather expensive collection of little extras. The good news is that a memorable spread doesn’t depend on fancy cheese, nuts or half a dozen specialty ingredients. Give ordinary potatoes a crispy edge, roast carrots until they’re glossy, or put a bowl of sharp, colorful cabbage beside the richer dishes, and suddenly those everyday vegetables look right at home at a holiday dinner.

I’ve included the familiar favorites as well as a few less obvious sides made with cabbage, beans, lentils and grains. Mix something creamy with something crisp, and try to balance oven dishes with stovetop options so you aren’t playing Thanksgiving Tetris with the roasting pans. A few recipes call for maple syrup, cream, cheese or fresh herbs, so check the full ingredient list and choose the ones that make sense for your own grocery prices and pantry.

Potatoes with something extra

1. Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Mashed potatoes rarely need much persuading to disappear, but garlic and chives make this batch feel a little more dressed up for Thanksgiving. Red potatoes, butter and a modest amount of cream do most of the work, with plenty of garlic for flavor. There are stovetop and Instant Pot instructions, which is particularly useful when every burner seems to have a job already.

Get the recipe

2. Scalloped Potatoes

Scalloped Potatoes
Image credit: Budget Bytes

A bubbling dish of scalloped potatoes looks wonderfully indulgent, yet the sauce here is made with milk, broth, butter and flour rather than a mountain of cheese. The thin potato slices become tender beneath that creamy topping, and the oven does the hard work. Just give this one a proper place in your cooking schedule, because it needs more oven time than a quick vegetable side.

Get the recipe

3. Pan-Fried Potatoes and Onions

Pan-Fried Potatoes and Onions
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

If you’ve already got stuffing, gravy and other soft dishes on the menu, these potatoes bring some much-needed crispness. Russets and a sweet onion develop lovely browned edges in a skillet, with smoked paprika and pantry seasonings adding flavor. There’s no cream or cheese to buy, although you’ll want to cook them close enough to dinner that those crisp edges stay crisp.

Get the recipe

4. Savory Rosemary Mashed Sweet Potatoes

Savory Rosemary Mashed Sweet Potatoes
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Sweet potatoes don’t need marshmallows to earn their place on the Thanksgiving table. Rosemary, salt, pepper and butter pull their natural sweetness in a savory direction, and you can brown the butter for a deeper, nuttier flavor if you fancy it. I’d choose this smooth mash when the rest of the menu already has plenty of sugary glazes and toppings.

Get the recipe

5. Old-Fashioned Candied Sweet Potatoes

Old-Fashioned Candied Sweet Potatoes
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

These are proper old-fashioned candied sweet potatoes, with thick slices that hold their shape beneath a glossy, spiced glaze. Cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg make the maple and brown sugar smell thoroughly festive. The maple syrup and whole stick of butter are worth accounting for in the budget, though. Bourbon or rum is optional in the original recipe, so there’s no reason to buy a bottle just for this dish.

Get the recipe

Colorful roots and winter squash

6. Brown Sugar Glazed Carrots

Brown Sugar Glazed Carrots
Image credit: Helene Dsouza / Masala Herb

Carrots are remarkably good at looking as though you’ve gone to a lot of trouble. Roast them in long pieces rather than chopping them into little rounds, then coat them with butter and just a tablespoon of brown sugar. You get shiny, lightly caramelized carrots that look lovely on a serving platter, using five ordinary ingredients.

Get the recipe

7. Carrot Casserole with Stuffing Topping

Carrot Casserole with Stuffing Topping
Image credit: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie

Carrots become something altogether more substantial under a crunchy stuffing topping. This casserole combines them with onion, cream of celery soup and a little cheddar, then uses boxed stuffing for that familiar holiday finish. It’s the one to pick if you’re after a proper comfort-food casserole, rather than another tray of roasted vegetables. Remember that the recipe uses butter in both the filling and topping when you’re planning the shopping.

Get the recipe

8. Roasted Turnips and Carrots

Roasted Turnips and Carrots
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Turnips are easy to overlook, especially when potatoes get all the attention. Roasted alongside carrots, their slightly peppery, earthy flavor is a welcome contrast to the sweeter roots. Oil, salt and pepper do the essential work, while the butter and parsley are optional. If turnips are reasonably priced where you shop, this is a good way to give them a place on the holiday table.

Get the recipe

9. Rosemary Roasted Parsnips

Rosemary Roasted Parsnips
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Parsnips get wonderfully sweet as they roast, with those slender edges turning golden and a little crisp. Rosemary and garlic are all they need to taste like something you planned for a special occasion. They’re particularly appealing when you want a different root vegetable without adding a sauce or casserole. Do compare the price first, though; parsnips aren’t a bargain in every grocery store.

Get the recipe

10. Balsamic Roasted Beets

Balsamic Roasted Beets
Image credit: Helene Dsouza / Masala Herb

Beets bring color to the Thanksgiving table that no amount of golden stuffing can compete with. These are roasted simply, then dressed with a little balsamic vinegar to sharpen their earthy sweetness. There are no walnuts, goat cheese or other extras to hunt down. Serve them in their own bowl if you’d rather they didn’t turn the neighboring mashed potatoes pink.

Get the recipe

11. Skillet Butternut Squash

Skillet Butternut Squash
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Butternut squash doesn’t have to fight the turkey for oven space. This version cooks small squash cubes in a skillet, with cinnamon, black pepper and a little honey or maple syrup to finish. It’s an appealing choice when you want that warm fall flavor but can’t squeeze in another roasting tray. A whole squash also gives you control over the size of the pieces, without paying for the convenience of a pre-cut pack.

Get the recipe

12. Roasted Acorn Squash with Raisins

Roasted Acorn Squash with Raisins
Image credit: Budget Bytes

Acorn squash has those pretty scalloped edges that make even simple slices look special. This recipe roasts them with garlic, poultry seasoning and a small amount of brown sugar, then adds raisins for little bursts of sweetness. It’s a pleasing mixture of savory and sweet, without a costly nut topping. Check the price of the squash itself before committing, as that’s the ingredient most likely to determine the cost.

Get the recipe

Green vegetables, cabbage and onions

13. Balsamic Roasted Brussels Sprouts

Balsamic Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

The secret to good roasted Brussels sprouts is getting those cut sides beautifully browned. Garlic, paprika and balsamic vinegar give this batch plenty of flavor, with none of the bacon, nuts or elaborate toppings that can quickly increase the bill. You get crisp-edged sprouts that can hold their own among the richer Thanksgiving dishes.

Get the recipe

14. Garlic Green Beans

Garlic Green Beans
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

I like having at least one green vegetable on the table that isn’t hiding under a creamy topping. These green beans are cooked in a skillet with slices of garlic and a little butter or olive oil, so they still taste distinctly of green beans. The recipe allows water instead of vegetable broth, which saves opening a carton just for half a cup. Simple, fresh and a welcome break between heavier spoonfuls.

Get the recipe

15. Creamed Spinach with Cream Cheese

Creamed Spinach with Cream Cheese
Image credit: Helene Dsouza / Masala Herb

Frozen spinach is a very sensible starting point for a holiday side, especially when fresh bags are expensive. Here, onion, garlic, cream cheese, milk and shredded cheese turn it into something rich enough to stand alongside the casseroles. Cheddar is one of the cheese options, so there’s no need to buy Parmesan just for this. It does use a fair amount of dairy, though, so it’s best value when those ingredients fit the rest of your menu.

Get the recipe

16. Lemon-Garlic Roasted Broccoli and Cauliflower

Lemon-Garlic Roasted Broccoli and Cauliflower
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Roasting brings out the sweet, nutty edges of broccoli and cauliflower, while garlic and lemon keep the whole dish lively. Putting both vegetables on the same tray gives you a pleasing mixture of shapes and textures without another pan to wash. The Parmesan is optional, so you can skip it if the budget is already doing enough stretching.

Get the recipe

17. Seared Cabbage Steaks with Gravy

Seared Cabbage Steaks with Gravy
Image credit: Budget Bytes

Cabbage is far more interesting when it’s seared in thick pieces instead of being boiled into submission. These cabbage steaks finish in the oven, then get a savory gravy made with broth, tomato paste and balsamic vinegar. There’s a skillet and an oven step involved, but a humble head of cabbage becomes a surprisingly substantial holiday dish. The gravy is the clever part, so don’t skip straight to serving the cabbage plain.

Get the recipe

18. Braised Red Cabbage with Apple

Braised Red Cabbage with Apple
Image credit: Holly Nilsson / Spend With Pennies

Red cabbage is one of those dishes that quietly makes a plate of turkey, potatoes and stuffing taste better. Simmer it with apple, onion, cider vinegar and a little clove, and you get soft, sweet-tart cabbage with a glorious deep purple color. It’s especially handy alongside richer foods, where something sharp is welcome. The ingredient list is pleasingly ordinary, without wine or jars of specialty preserves.

Get the recipe

19. Buttered Peas with Onion

Buttered Peas with Onion
Image credit: Helene Dsouza / Masala Herb

A bag of frozen peas can be worth its weight in gold when you’re juggling a holiday dinner. Soften an onion, add the peas, then finish them with a little butter and black pepper for a bright green side that doesn’t occupy the oven. This is the one I’d keep in reserve when the rest of the menu is getting a bit too ambitious.

Get the recipe

20. Creamed Pearl Onions

Creamed Pearl Onions
Image credit: Holly Nilsson / Spend With Pennies

Creamed pearl onions have a wonderfully old-fashioned holiday feel, and the little whole onions look rather more elegant than their modest ingredients suggest. They sit in a silky sauce with cream, broth and a scattering of Parmesan. Frozen, already-peeled pearl onions can save a fiddly preparation job. Compare their price with fresh ones before deciding, as these small onions aren’t always as economical as ordinary onions.

Get the recipe

Grains and beans that earn their place

21. Broccoli, Cheddar and Rice Casserole

Broccoli, Cheddar and Rice Casserole
Image credit: Budget Bytes

Rice helps turn a pan of broccoli and cheddar into a generous, comforting casserole. This version uses frozen broccoli and a homemade cheese sauce, so you don’t need canned cream soup, and each scoop has plenty of substance. The two cups of cheddar are the main indulgence here, but they’re spread through a whole dish rather than piled onto individual portions.

Get the recipe

22. Mushroom-Barley Pilaf

Mushroom-Barley Pilaf
Image credit: Regi Pearce / Nuts & Twigs

Pearl barley has a satisfying chew that makes a welcome change from all the soft Thanksgiving sides. Toast it, then cook it with mushrooms, onion, celery and thyme for a deeply savory pilaf. Ordinary button mushrooms are a perfectly good choice, and the optional tahini-lemon sauce isn’t necessary for the dish to work. This is an especially good option when you’d like something hearty without another cheesy bake.

Get the recipe

23. Greek Spinach Rice

Greek Spinach Rice
Image credit: Plantbasedredhead

Greek spinach rice, or spanakorizo, brings lemon and fresh dill to the table, two flavors that make a real difference after several bites of rich holiday food. The rice and spinach cook together, so it’s substantial without being heavy. Fresh dill is part of this particular recipe, so account for that in the shopping; the optional vegan feta and other toppings can stay off the list.

Get the recipe

24. White Bean Mash with Rosemary and Lemon

White Bean Mash with Rosemary and Lemon
Image credit: Emily / Inside the Rustic Kitchen

Cannellini beans mash into something beautifully creamy with olive oil, garlic, lemon and rosemary. The flavor is bright and herby, so it offers a change from another bowl of buttery potatoes without requiring cream or cheese. Using cooked or canned beans keeps the preparation straightforward. It’s a particularly appealing side if you want to make room for beans without serving a conventional bean salad.

Get the recipe

25. Lentils with Creamy Mushroom Gravy

Lentils with Creamy Mushroom Gravy
Image credit: Budget Bytes

Brown lentils and mushrooms make a thick, savory dish that looks right at home beside Thanksgiving vegetables. Sage and thyme give it those familiar holiday flavors, while coconut milk turns the cooking liquid into a creamy gravy. Dried lentils are inexpensive, but do include the can of coconut milk in your budget. Serve it in a bowl as a hearty plant-based side, with no need to build an entire separate dinner around it.

Get the recipe

26. Black-Eyed Peas with Collards

Black-Eyed Peas with Collards
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Black-eyed peas and collard greens make a smoky, filling side, especially if you already have a meaty ham bone to put to use. The Instant Pot cooks dried peas with onion, celery, bacon and a ham hock, building plenty of flavor into the beans. This isn’t a meat-free bargain recipe, and buying a ham hock solely for it may change the economics. It’s a stronger budget choice when that smoky ingredient is already in the kitchen.

Get the recipe

27. Four-Bean Salad

Four-Bean Salad
Image credit: Stacie Vaughan / Simply Stacie

After several hot, rich dishes, a cold bean salad can be a very welcome sight. This one combines canned green, wax, kidney and broad or lima beans with onion and pepper in a sweet-sharp vinegar dressing. The different beans give it real variety of color and bite, and there’s no last-minute oven juggling. It’s also a good option for getting part of the Thanksgiving spread prepared ahead.

Get the recipe

Corn, stuffing and breads

28. Homemade Herb and Mushroom Stuffing

Homemade Herb and Mushroom Stuffing
Image credit: Kate Dean / I Heart Eating

Day-old bread is the foundation of a very good stuffing, and this version makes it properly savory with mushrooms, onion, celery, sage and thyme. The pieces on top turn crisp while the middle stays soft enough to soak up gravy. There’s no sausage or nut mixture to buy, and you can put that stale-but-sound bread to much better use than leaving it on the counter.

Get the recipe

29. Jiffy Corn Casserole

Jiffy Corn Casserole
Image credit: Kate Dean / I Heart Eating

Jiffy corn casserole sits somewhere between cornbread and a soft, scoopable pudding, which is exactly why it goes down so well with a holiday meal. A box of corn muffin mix and cans of whole and creamed corn provide the base, while sour cream and butter make it rich. You don’t need to add cheese or make a separate cornbread batter, but do count those dairy ingredients when comparing recipes.

Get the recipe

30. Buttery Skillet Corn

Buttery Skillet Corn
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Fresh corn on the cob can be a rather expensive ambition in November. Frozen kernels work in this skillet recipe, with butter, garlic powder and pepper giving them a simple, savory finish. It’s quick enough to cook while the turkey rests, and it leaves the oven free for the dishes that genuinely need it.

Get the recipe

31. Pumpkin Dinner Rolls

Pumpkin Dinner Rolls
Image credit: Anthea / Rainbow Nourishments

Pumpkin gives these yeast rolls their lovely golden color and helps make them soft and tender. They’re an inviting way to put a little fall flavor into the bread basket, and the original recipe is vegan. It uses plant-based milk and vegan butter, so I’d choose it when those are already kitchen staples rather than buying both specifically to make a budget batch of rolls. Allow time for the yeast dough to rise.

Get the recipe

32. Irish Brown Soda Bread

Irish Brown Soda Bread
Image credit: Kate Dean / I Heart Eating

There’s something very satisfying about a sturdy slice of brown soda bread beside a generous spoonful of gravy. This loaf uses whole wheat and all-purpose flour, buttermilk and everyday raising agents, so there’s no yeast or long rise to organize. It isn’t a delicate dinner roll, and that’s part of its appeal: a hearty, sliceable loaf that can cope with a busy holiday plate.

Get the recipe

33. Everyday Cornbread

Everyday Cornbread
Image credit: Budget Bytes

Sometimes a pan of straightforward cornbread is exactly what’s needed. Cornmeal, flour, milk, egg and oil make this version without a boxed mix, fancy cheese or other extras. It’s easy to cut into squares and pass around the table, particularly if there are plenty of saucy dishes that need something to mop them up. Save the elaborate toppings for a side that actually needs them.

Get the recipe

Something bright for the plate

34. Apple Cranberry Sauce

Apple Cranberry Sauce
Image credit: Spoonful of Flavor

Cranberry sauce is especially welcome when the rest of Thanksgiving dinner is rich and buttery. Apples give this version more body and gentle sweetness, while ginger, orange and balsamic vinegar keep the flavor bright. The honey and fresh orange do add to the cost, so check what you’ve already got in the pantry before choosing it. It’s a colorful little bowl that earns its space on the table.

Get the recipe

35. Rutabaga Apple Slaw

Rutabaga Apple Slaw
Image credit: Elizabeth Lampman / Frugal Mom Eh!

Rutabaga doesn’t get much attention until you grate it with tart apples, carrot and red cabbage and discover how good it is raw. This slaw is crisp, colorful and dressed with mustard, cider vinegar and a little honey, providing a refreshing contrast to all the warm, soft dishes. Rutabaga prices vary, so buy it when it’s good value rather than assuming every root vegetable is automatically cheap.

Get the recipe

You might also like…

25 Thanksgiving Side Dishes That Don’t Need the Oven

15 Cozy Thanksgiving Desserts to Sweeten the Season

21 Easy Thanksgiving Breakfast and Brunch Recipes

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *